comparison between eyeliners (MAC, UD, Clinique, andt styli style)

Here is a comparison between the four eyeliners that i carry around with me. their fast easy and no fuss. these are my most used liners other then my black tract and i love them

This picture was taken at 10 in the morning i had nothing to do in class so i decided to do an experiment

Left to right
(urban decay lust, styli style black/brown, clinique 01 new black, mac penultimate eyeliner)

This was taken at 6pm with alot of rubbing and we can clearly see that all of them are smudging a little except for the styli style (I have to say i rubbed pretty hard and their still pretty in tact)

and Lastly this was taken after i ran my hand under water and i rubbed it a little (i must say i still love them regardless)

1. urban decay lust
( at macys the dude put that liner on my hand rubbed it out and spray water on my hand and rubbed hella hard but nothing can off so i don't know whats with my liner i have to say i'm not in love with it because it's really creamy the tip constantly has to be sharpened for me to draw a thin line)

2. style style black/brown
( this liner is AWSOME it's cheep it's strong it barely needs sharpening and for some reason i have really good control with this liner i would pick this over urban decay anyday save yourself some money it's worth it you can find this awsome liner at most riteaids)

3. Clinique 01 new black
( this was my 1st eyeliner ever and I've been using it ever since it i sometimes use it for tightlining because its a twist up liner but i must say it does not stay on my waterline at all so i probably won't get it again)

4. Mac penultimate liner in rapidblack
(like i said before this is the only liquid eyeliner i can use when i want a more dramatic look i will use this liner it's not water proof at all but i love it it's amazing but i'm trying to look for a replacement it's too expensive for something that's only good for 3-6 months)